Command Dispatching

Command dispatching, as exemplified in the Dispatching Commands page, has a number of advantages. First of all, there is a single object that clearly describes the intent of the client. By logging the command, you store both the intent and related data for future reference. Command handling also makes it easy to expose your command processing components to remote clients, via web services for example. Testing also becomes a lot easier, you could define test scripts by just defining the starting situation (given), command to execute (when) and expected results (then) by listing a number of events and commands (see Testing for more on this). The last major advantage is that it is very easy to switch between synchronous and asynchronous as well as local versus distributed command processing.

This does not mean command dispatching using explicit command object is the only way to do it. The goal of Axon is not to prescribe a specific way of working, but to support you doing it your way, while providing best practices as the default behavior. It is still possible to use a service layer that you can invoke to execute commands. The method will just need to start a unit of work (see Unit of Work) and perform a commit or rollback on it when the method is finished.

The next sections provide an overview of the tasks related to setting up a command dispatching infrastructure with the Axon Framework.

The Command Gateway

The Command Gateway is a convenient interface towards the command dispatching mechanism. While you are not required to use a gateway to dispatch commands, it is generally the easiest option to do so.

There are two ways to use a Command Gateway. The first is to use the CommandGateway interface and the DefaultCommandGateway implementation provided by Axon. The command gateway provides a number of methods that allow you to send a command and wait for a result either synchronously, with a timeout or asynchronously.

The other option is perhaps the most flexible of all. You can turn almost any interface into a command gateway using the CommandGatewayFactory. This allows you to define your application's interface using strong typing and declaring your own (checked) business exceptions. Axon will automatically generate an implementation for that interface at runtime.

Configuring the Command Gateway

Both your custom Command Gateway and the one provided by Axon need to at least be configured with a Command Bus. In addition, the Command Gateway can be configured with a RetryScheduler, CommandDispatchInterceptors, and CommandCallbacks.

RetryScheduler

The RetryScheduler is capable of scheduling retries when command execution has failed. When a command fails due to an exception that is explicitly non-transient, no retries are done at all. Note that the retry scheduler is only invoked when a command fails due to a RuntimeException. Checked exceptions are regarded "business exception" and will never trigger a retry.

Currently two implementations exist:

  1. The IntervalRetryScheduler will retry a given command at set intervals until it succeeds,

    or a maximum number of retries has taken place.

  2. The ExponentialBackOffIntervalRetryScheduler retries failed commands with an exponential back-off interval until

    it succeeds, or a maximum number of retries has taken place.

CommandDispatchInterceptor

CommandDispatchInterceptors allow modification of CommandMessages prior to dispatching them to the Command Bus. In contrast to CommandDispatchInterceptors configured on the Command Bus, these interceptors are only invoked when messages are sent through this Gateway. The interceptors can be used to attach metadata to a command or do validation, for example.

CommandCallback

A CommandCallback can be provided to the Command Gateway upon a regular send, specifying what to do with the command handling result. It works with the CommandMessage and CommandResultMessage classes, thus allowing for some generic behavior for all Commands sent through this gateway regardless of their type.

Creating a custom Command Gateway

Axon allows a custom interface to be used as a command gateway. The behavior of each method declared in the interface is based on the parameter types, return type and declared exception. Using this gateway is not only convenient, it makes testing a lot easier by allowing you to mock your interface where needed.

This is how parameters affect the behavior of the command gateway:

  • The first parameter is expected to be the actual command object to dispatch.

  • Parameters annotated with @MetaDataValue will have their value assigned to the metadata field with the identifier passed as annotation parameter

  • Parameters of type MetaData will be merged with the MetaData on the CommandMessage.

    Metadata defined by latter parameters will overwrite the metadata of earlier parameters, if their key is equal.

  • Parameters of type CommandCallback will have their onSuccess or onFailure invoked after the command is handled.

    You may pass in more than one callback, and it may be combined with a return value. In that case, the invocations of the callback will always match with the return value (or exception).

  • The last two parameters may be of types long (or int) and TimeUnit.

    In that case the method will block at most as long as these parameters indicate. How the method reacts on a timeout depends on the exceptions declared on the method (see below).

    Note that if other properties of the method prevent blocking altogether, a timeout will never occur.

The declared return value of a method will also affect its behavior:

  • A void return type will cause the method to return immediately, unless there are other indications on the method that one would want to wait, such as a timeout or declared exceptions.

  • Return types of Future, CompletionStage and CompletableFuture will cause the method to return immediately.

    You can access the result of the command handler using the CompletableFuture instance returned from the method.

    Exceptions and timeouts declared on the method are ignored.

  • Any other return type will cause the method to block until a result is available.

    The result is cast to the return type (causing a ClassCastException if the types do not match).

Exceptions have the following effect:

  • Any declared checked exception will be thrown if the command handler (or an interceptor) threw an exception of that type.

    If a checked exception is thrown that has not been declared, it is wrapped in a CommandExecutionException, which is a RuntimeException.

  • When a timeout occurs, the default behavior is to return null from the method.

    This can be changed by declaring a TimeoutException.

    If this exception is declared, a TimeoutException is thrown instead.

  • When a thread is interrupted while waiting for a result, the default behavior is to return null.

    In that case, the interrupted flag is set back on the thread.

    By declaring an InterruptedException on the method, this behavior is changed to throw that exception instead.

    The interrupt flag is removed when the exception is thrown, consistent with the java specification.

  • Other runtime exceptions may be declared on the method, but will not have any effect other than clarification to the API user.

Finally, there is the possibility to use annotations:

  • As specified in the parameter section, the @MetaDataValue annotation on a parameter will have the value of that parameter added as metadata value.

    The key of the metadata entry is provided as parameter to the annotation.

  • Methods annotated with @Timeout will block at most the indicated amount of time.

    This annotation is ignored if the method declares timeout parameters.

  • Classes annotated with @Timeout will cause all methods declared in that class to block at most the indicated amount of time, unless they are annotated with their own @Timeout annotation or specify timeout parameters.

public interface MyGateway {
// fire and forget
void sendCommand(MyPayloadType command);
// method that attaches metadata and will wait for a result for 10 seconds
@Timeout(value = 10, unit = TimeUnit.SECONDS)
ReturnValue sendCommandAndWaitForAResult(MyPayloadType command,
@MetaDataValue("userId") String userId);
// alternative that throws exceptions on timeout
@Timeout(value = 20, unit = TimeUnit.SECONDS)
ReturnValue sendCommandAndWaitForAResult(MyPayloadType command)
throws TimeoutException, InterruptedException;
// this method will also wait, caller decides how long
void sendCommandAndWait(MyPayloadType command, long timeout, TimeUnit unit)
throws TimeoutException, InterruptedException;
}
// To configure a gateway:
CommandGatewayFactory factory = CommandGatewayFactory.builder()
.commandBus(commandBus)
.build();
// note that the commandBus can be obtained from the Configuration
// object returned on `configurer.initialize()`.
MyGateway myGateway = factory.createGateway(MyGateway.class);

The Command Bus

The Command Bus is the mechanism that dispatches commands to their respective command handlers within an Axon application. Suggestions on how to use the CommandBus can be found here. Several flavors of the command bus, with differing characteristics, exist within the framework:

AxonServerCommandBus

Axon provides a command bus out of the box, the AxonServerCommandBus. It connects to the AxonIQ AxonServer Server to submit and receive Commands.

AxonServerCommandBus is a distributed command bus. It is using SimpleCommandBus to handle incoming commands on different JVM's by default.

Axon Configuration API
Spring Boot AutoConfiguration

Declare dependencies:

<!--somewhere in the POM file-->
<dependency>
<groupId>org.axonframework</groupId>
<artifactId>axon-server-connector</artifactId>
<version>${axon.version}</version>
</dependency>
<dependency>
<groupId>org.axonframework</groupId>
<artifactId>axon-configuration</artifactId>
<version>${axon.version}</version>
</dependency>

Configure your application:

// Returns a Configurer instance with default components configured. `AxonServerCommandBus` is configured as Command Bus by default.
Configurer configurer = DefaultConfigurer.defaultConfiguration();

Excluding the Axon Server Connector

If you exclude axon-server-connector dependency you will fallback to 'non-axon-server' command bus options, the SimpleCommandBus (see below).

By simply declaring dependency to axon-spring-boot-starter, Axon will automatically configure the Axon Server Command Bus:

<!--somewhere in the POM file-->
<dependency>
<groupId>org.axonframework</groupId>
<artifactId>axon-spring-boot-starter</artifactId>
<version>${axon.version}</version>
</dependency>

SimpleCommandBus

The SimpleCommandBus is, as the name suggests, the simplest implementation. It does straightforward processing of commands in the thread that dispatches them. After a command is processed, the modified aggregate(s) are saved and generated events are published in that same thread. In most scenarios, such as web applications, this implementation will suit your needs.

Like most CommandBus implementations, the SimpleCommandBus allows interceptors to be configured. CommandDispatchInterceptors are invoked when a command is dispatched on the command bus. The CommandHandlerInterceptors are invoked before the actual command handler method is, allowing you to do modify or block the command. See Command interceptors for more information.

Since all command processing is done in the same thread, this implementation is limited to the JVM's boundaries. The performance of this implementation is good, but not extraordinary. To cross JVM boundaries, or to get the most out of your CPU cycles, check out the other CommandBus implementations.

Axon Configuration API
Spring Boot AutoConfiguration
Configurer configurer = DefaultConfigurer.defaultConfiguration()
.configureCommandBus(c -> SimpleCommandBus.builder().transactionManager(c.getComponent(TransactionManager.class)).messageMonitor(c.messageMonitor(SimpleCommandBus.class, "commandBus")).build());
@Bean
public SimpleCommandBus commandBus(TransactionManager txManager, AxonConfiguration axonConfiguration) {
SimpleCommandBus commandBus =
SimpleCommandBus.builder()
.transactionManager(txManager)
.messageMonitor(axonConfiguration.messageMonitor(CommandBus.class, "commandBus"))
.build();
commandBus.registerHandlerInterceptor(
new CorrelationDataInterceptor<>(axonConfiguration.correlationDataProviders())
);
return commandBus;
}

Excluding the Axon Server Connector

If you exclude the axon-server-connector dependency from the axon-spring-boot-starter dependency, the SimpleCommandBus will be auto-configured for you.

AsynchronousCommandBus

As the name suggest, the AsynchronousCommandBus implementation executes commands asynchronously from the thread that dispatches them. It uses an Executor to perform the actual handling logic on a different Thread.

By default, the AsynchronousCommandBus uses an unbounded cached thread pool. This means a thread is created when a command is dispatched. Threads that have finished processing a command are reused for new commands. Threads are stopped if they have not processed a command for 60 seconds.

Alternatively, an Executor instance may be provided to configure a different threading strategy.

Note that the AsynchronousCommandBus should be shut down when stopping the application, to make sure any waiting threads are properly shut down. To shut down, call the shutdown() method. This will also shutdown any provided Executor instance, if it implements the ExecutorService interface.

Axon Configuration API
Spring Boot AutoConfiguration
Configurer configurer = DefaultConfigurer.defaultConfiguration()
.configureCommandBus(c -> AsynchronousCommandBus.builder().transactionManager(c.getComponent(TransactionManager.class))
.messageMonitor(c.messageMonitor(AsynchronousCommandBus.class, "commandBus"))
.build());
@Bean
public AsynchronousCommandBus commandBus(TransactionManager txManager, AxonConfiguration axonConfiguration) {
AsynchronousCommandBus commandBus =
AsynchronousCommandBus.builder()
.transactionManager(txManager)
.messageMonitor(axonConfiguration.messageMonitor(AsynchronousCommandBus.class, "commandBus"))
.build();
commandBus.registerHandlerInterceptor(new CorrelationDataInterceptor<>(axonConfiguration.correlationDataProviders()));
return commandBus;
}

DisruptorCommandBus

The SimpleCommandBus has reasonable performance characteristics. The fact that the SimpleCommandBus needs locking to prevent multiple threads from concurrently accessing the same aggregate causes processing overhead and lock contention.

The DisruptorCommandBus takes a different approach to multithreaded processing. Instead of having multiple threads each doing the same process, there are multiple threads, each taking care of a piece of the process. The DisruptorCommandBus uses the Disruptor, a small framework for concurrent programming, to achieve much better performance, by just taking a different approach to multi-threading. Instead of doing the processing in the calling thread, the tasks are handed off to two groups of threads, that each take care of a part of the processing. The first group of threads will execute the command handler, changing an aggregate's state. The second group will store and publish the events to the event store.

While the DisruptorCommandBus easily outperforms the SimpleCommandBus by a factor of 4(!), there are a few limitations:

  • The DisruptorCommandBus only supports event sourced aggregates.

    This Command Bus also acts as a Repository for the aggregates processed by the Disruptor.

    To get a reference to the Repository, use createRepository(AggregateFactory).

  • A command can only result in a state change in a single aggregate instance.

  • When using a cache, it allows only a single aggregate for a given identifier.

    This means it is not possible to have two aggregates of different types with the same identifier.

  • Commands should generally not cause a failure that requires a rollback of the unit of work.

    When a rollback occurs, the DisruptorCommandBus cannot guarantee that commands are processed in the order they were dispatched.

    Furthermore, it requires a retry of a number of other commands, causing unnecessary computations.

  • When creating a new aggregate Instance, commands updating that created instance may not all happen in the exact order as provided.

    Once the aggregate is created, all commands will be executed exactly in the order they were dispatched.

    To ensure the order, use a callback on the creating command to wait for the aggregate being created.

    It shouldn't take more than a few milliseconds.

To construct a DisruptorCommandBus instance, you need an EventStore. This component is explained in the Event Bus and Event Store section.

Optionally, you can provide a DisruptorConfiguration instance, which allows you to tweak the configuration to optimize performance for your specific environment:

  • Buffer size - the number of slots on the ring buffer to register incoming commands.

    Higher values may increase throughput, but also cause higher latency. Must always be a power of 2. Defaults to 4096.

  • ProducerType - indicates whether the entries are produced by a single thread, or multiple. Defaults to multiple.

  • WaitStrategy - the strategy to use when the processor threads (the three threads taking care of the actual processing) need to wait for each other.

    The best wait strategy depends on the number of cores available in the machine, and the number of other processes running.

    If low latency is crucial, and the DisruptorCommandBus may claim cores for itself, you can use the BusySpinWaitStrategy.

    To make the command bus claim less of the CPU and allow other threads to do processing, use the YieldingWaitStrategy.

    Finally, you can use the SleepingWaitStrategy and BlockingWaitStrategy to allow other processes a fair share of CPU.

    The latter is suitable if the Command Bus is not expected to be processing full-time.

    Defaults to the BlockingWaitStrategy.

  • Executor - sets the Executor that provides the Threads for the DisruptorCommandBus.

    This executor must be able to provide at least four threads.

    Three of the threads are claimed by the processing components of the DisruptorCommandBus.

    Extra threads are used to invoke callbacks and to schedule retries in case an Aggregate's state is detected to be corrupt.

    Defaults to a CachedThreadPool that provides threads from a thread group called "DisruptorCommandBus".

  • TransactionManager - defines the transaction manager that should ensure that the storage and publication of events are executed within a transaction.

  • InvokerInterceptors - defines the CommandHandlerInterceptors that are to be used in the invocation process.

    This is the process that calls the actual Command Handler method.

  • PublisherInterceptors - defines the CommandHandlerInterceptors that are to be used in the publication process.

    This is the process that stores and publishes the generated events.

  • RollbackConfiguration - defines on which Exceptions a Unit of Work should be rolled back.

    Defaults to a configuration that rolls back on unchecked exceptions.

  • RescheduleCommandsOnCorruptState - indicates whether Commands that have been executed against an Aggregate that has been corrupted (e.g. because a Unit of Work was rolled back) should be rescheduled.

    If false the callback's onFailure() method will be invoked.

    If true (the default), the command will be rescheduled instead.

  • CoolingDownPeriod - sets the number of seconds to wait to make sure all commands are processed.

    During the cooling down period, no new commands are accepted, but existing commands are processed, and rescheduled when necessary.

    The cooling down period ensures that threads are available for rescheduling the commands and calling callbacks.

    Defaults to 1000 (1 second).

  • Cache - sets the cache that stores aggregate instances that have been reconstructed from the Event Store.

    The cache is used to store aggregate instances that are not in active use by the disruptor.

  • InvokerThreadCount - the number of threads to assign to the invocation of command handlers.

    A good starting point is half the number of cores in the machine.

  • PublisherThreadCount - the number of threads to use to publish events.

    A good starting point is half the number of cores, and could be increased if a lot of time is spent on I/O.

  • SerializerThreadCount - the number of threads to use to pre-serialize events.

    This defaults to 1, but is ignored if no serializer is configured.

  • Serializer - the serializer to perform pre-serialization with.

    When a serializer is configured, the DisruptorCommandBus will wrap all generated events in a SerializationAware message.

    The serialized form of the payload and metadata is attached before they are published to the Event Store.

Axon Configuration API
Spring Boot AutoConfiguration
Configurer configurer = DefaultConfigurer.defaultConfiguration()
.configureCommandBus(c ->
DisruptorCommandBus.builder()
.transactionManager(c.getComponent(TransactionManager.class))
.messageMonitor(c.messageMonitor(DisruptorCommandBus.class, "commandBus"))
.bufferSize(4096)
.build()
);
@Bean
public DisruptorCommandBus commandBus(TransactionManager txManager, AxonConfiguration axonConfiguration) {
DisruptorCommandBus commandBus =
DisruptorCommandBus.builder()
.transactionManager(txManager)
.messageMonitor(axonConfiguration.messageMonitor(DisruptorCommandBus.class, "commandBus"))
.build();
commandBus.registerHandlerInterceptor(new CorrelationDataInterceptor<>(axonConfiguration.correlationDataProviders()));
return commandBus;
}

Distributing the Command Bus

Sometimes, you want multiple instances of command buses in different JVMs to act as one. Commands dispatched on one JVM's command bus should be seamlessly transported to a command handler in another JVM while sending back any results.

That is where the concept of 'distributing the command bus' comes in. The default implementation of a distributed command bus is the AxonServerCommandBus. It connects to the AxonIQ AxonServer Server to submit and receive Commands. Unlike the other CommandBus implementations, the AxonServerCommandBus does not invoke any handlers at all. All it does is form a "bridge" between command bus implementations on different JVM's.

By default, SimpleCommandBus is configured to handle incoming commands on the different JVM's. You can configure AxonServerCommandBus to use other command bus implementations for this purposes: AsynchronousCommandBus, DisruptorCommandBus.

DistributedCommandBus

DistributedCommandBus is an alternative approach to distributing command bus (commands). Each instance of the DistributedCommandBus on each JVM is called a "Segment".

Structure of the Distributed Command Bus

The DistributedCommandBus relies on two components: a CommandBusConnector, which implements the communication protocol between the JVM's, and the CommandRouter, which chooses a destination for each incoming command. This router defines which segment of the DistributedCommandBus should be given a `command, based on a routing key calculated by a routing strategy. Two commands with the same routing key will always be routed to the same segment, as long as there is no change in the number and configuration of the segments. Generally, the identifier of the targeted aggregate is used as a routing key.

Two implementations of the RoutingStrategy are provided: the MetaDataRoutingStrategy, which uses a metadata property in the command message to find the routing key, and the AnnotationRoutingStrategy, which uses the @TargetAggregateIdentifier annotation on the Command Messages payload to extract the routing key. Obviously, you can also provide your own implementation.

By default, the RoutingStrategy implementations will throw an exception when no key can be resolved from a command message. This behavior can be altered by providing a UnresolvedRoutingKeyPolicy in the constructor of the MetaDataRoutingStrategy or AnnotationRoutingStrategy. There are three possible policies:

  • ERROR - the default, and will cause an exception to be thrown when a Routing Key is not available

  • RANDOM_KEY - will return a random value when a `routing key cannot be resolved from the command message.

    This effectively means that those commands will be routed to a random segment of the command bus.

  • STATIC_KEY - Will return a static key (being "unresolved") for unresolved routing keys.

    This effectively means that all those commands will be routed to the same segment, as long as the configuration of segments does not change.

You can choose different flavor of this components that are available in one of the extension modules:

Spring Boot AutoConfiguration

Configuring a distributed command bus can (mostly) be done without any modifications in configuration files.

First of all, the starters for one of the Axon distributed command bus modules needs to be included (e.g. JGroups or Spring Cloud).

Once that is present, a single property needs to be added to the application context, to enable the distributed command bus:

axon.distributed.enabled=true

There in one setting that is independent of the type of connector used:

axon.distributed.load-factor=100